Somewhere in My Memory
There are places where we never want to return and others that we wish we never had to leave. It’s funny, isn’t it, how we’re so tethered to places that the thought of them can conjure smells, sounds, tears, even yearning; how we can close our eyes and we’re there again.
It was a Friday in 2017 when my little boy passed away. I don’t recall much of the days that followed, but I remember it was Tuesday when my husband knelt by the bed and said it was time to pick a church for Max’s service. He said he and friends found a good one they wanted to show me. Before I even saw it, my first thought was of windows. The church had to have windows and natural light flooding a traditional sanctuary with wooden pews.
As it turned out, the church they found was like a theater – a chapel with no windows, just rows of chairs and a stage (like the church we attend now). I’m well-known for second-guessing but was resolute in my decision. The service had to be in a church with windows.
I got on my computer and searched for traditional churches near us. I wanted a steeple, pews, stained glass windows. A dark room didn’t feel right to celebrate the life of my Max, a child who glowed from the inside out.
As I examined the image of a beautiful church on my screen, I received a phone call from our family pediatrician, a man I love dearly. I told him about my search for the perfect church and, as always, he had the answer.
“I have a friend who is the pastor at Johns Creek United Methodist Church. Let me give her a call.”
I looked over at the church on my computer and read the name: Johns Creek United Methodist Church. This is the place, I thought. And it was.
Every detail of Max’s service was beautiful. Mahogany pews filled with friends and family, music he loved, speakers who loved him, and radiant light streaming in through wall-to-wall windows. That sanctuary provided light in the darkness in more ways than one. It served a precious purpose, and I was, and will always be, so grateful that we were able to use that place to honor our boy. But when we turned out of the church parking lot, I prayed I would never have to see it again.
My youngest son Beau started piano lessons at age 5, and I was so happy. Our home has always been filled with music, but the idea of my children filling our walls with music of their own sounded dreamy. Beau took to piano quickly. His sharp little mind soaked up every note as his teensy fingers moved nimbly across the keys. About six months into his lessons, after he had mastered an entire Christmas song, his teacher mentioned a recital. I was instantly excited, picturing how adorable it would be to watch Beau perform before an audience for the first time. But that image was quickly snatched away when the teacher told me the location of the recital: Johns Creek United Methodist Church.
I didn’t want the teacher to know how my heart throbbed just by hearing the name of the church. I didn’t want him to know how hard I was working to not cry. Instead, I shook my head and lied. I told the teacher we had plans that weekend and Beau could not participate.
Soon after, our family went to Nashville for a weekend and stayed at a hotel with a grand piano in the lobby restaurant. Beau was enthralled by the glossy, onyx instrument and the bowtie clad pianist who played with his eyes closed. When the pianist took a break, my brave little boy walked over and asked him if he could play a song on the piano. The pianist happily obliged, and my husband and I watched, equal parts nervous and tickled, as our baby slid onto the piano bench, his feet dangling many inches above the marble floor, and proceeded to play “We Three Kings” before a crowd of seated patrons. My eyes were tear-filled when he finished, and the crowd of strangers applauded. My little baby loved to perform, and I had said no to a recital, robbing him of an experience that he clearly loved. I felt terrible. I messaged the piano teacher and said he could perform in the recital. I promptly bought Beau the most perfect Christmas blazer and a gingerbread man bowtie.
When we entered the church lobby on the day of his performance, I made a concentrated effort to divert my eyes from the sanctuary. The recital was in the reception room across the way, where my husband and I had stood and received a generous line of friends and family after Max’s service. Other children performed one by one, and I barely noticed. I looked to the corner of the room and saw us there, my husband and I, each holding one of our younger boys, our first appearance as just four of us, not five. I was yanked out of my reverie when I heard Beau’s name. I melted as I watched him, so confident, so in his element. He performed wonderfully and polished it off with an adorable bow. He looked so happy, and I was so happy for him.
As the group of performers took a photo in the lobby afterward, I wandered to the sanctuary doors and looked inside. I saw the pew where my husband and I sat, clinging to one another. I saw the altar where photos of Max and our family had been displayed. Not a single light was turned on, but the room was illuminated, just as I remembered. My husband and I exchanged knowing looks as we turned to go get our little boy and give him a great big hug.
This year marked our third return to Johns Creek United Methodist Church for a piano recital. Beau, nearly 8 now, chose to play “Somewhere in My Memory,” a Christmas song from one of his favorite movies, “Home Alone.” I had heard the song countless times as Beau fumbled his way through the notes during lessons at home. His teacher warned it’d be a difficult one to learn, but Beau was stubborn, insistent that it had to be that song. The piano teacher taught Beau how to recover from a mistake. He showed him how to pick up at the beginning of the bar of music like nothing had happened; he told Beau not to react with his face or body, that it’s no problem if he messed up. But Beau didn’t make a single mistake in his performance. We watched in wonder as he hit every single note and took his bow. When we congratulated him afterward he said, “Once I got started, I knew I’d be OK.”
Beau has developed a passion for piano. I’m so proud of him and I know this means that many recitals lay ahead, many more visits to Johns Creek United Methodist Church. I never ever wanted to return there, but now I have. Like Beau, now that I’ve started, I know I’ll be OK.
I still see everything from Max’s service, the navy ribbon emblazoned with his name, his blanket and toy school bus at the altar. The church holds memories of the most broken version of myself, the me who wondered how life could possibly go on without my firstborn son.
It’s been seven years and the ache for our boy is as palpable as ever. But we are living proof that hearts still beat when they’re broken, and, like that church in Johns Creek, light still shines wherever there’s a window. I returned to a place I never wanted to see again and now that place holds new memories that mingle with the old - memories of precious songs, proud little smiles, and a family that may look like four but will forever be five.